Tuesday, September 16, 2014

Review: 75052 Mos Eisley Cantina


Set ID: 75052 Mos Eisley Cantina
Number of Pieces: 615
Year of Release: 2014
Minifigs: 8
Purchased Price: About SGD 150

Have been on the road for business for the last three weeks and there are plenty of things that I missed - the taste of authentic Singaporean local dishes, the smell of my kids, and the sense of fulfilment to build a really good LEGO Star Wars set. Before I was consumed totally by my withdrawal syndrome, I was glad to see that I had a few unopened sets at home at my disposal. Despite the huge distraction from my newly acquired UCS Sandcrawler, I reached out to this set instead. A set that hopefully tick all the right boxes.

I remembered when the rumour first appeared online that there was going to be a revised Mos Eisley Cantina set, the internet was abuzz with what the AFOLs hope to see in this new set. It has been a decade since the release of the previous (and first) version so it is understandable that expectations were high. The 2004 set can hardly qualify as a scene set, given that there were probably only enough bricks to build the Landspeeder, the Dewback and a few pieces of furniture for the minifigs to catch up on. In short, is it easy to do better than the 2004 set? Yes. Did this set achieve that? In some ways, at least for me. To be fair, I have never built the original version before (and I bet it is a rather hot item on the internet now. No?) so any comparison will never be an apple to apple one. So let me wear my 2014 lenses and see how this set fare...

The hovering one



How many Landspeeders did LEGO release before? Four? Five? I am not complaining but the quality of the Landspeeder has flat-lined since a couple of variants ago. But if I skip the few in between versions, and place this latest variant to the 1999's release, it was an apparent no contest. The colour of this version is the most movie accurate and it still comes with a concealed compartment for Luke to store his knick-knacks. The opening hatch is not too well designed so it does come off from time to time when I was trying to open it. Nine transparent circular 2X2 provides the slight elevation (can have more) and hovering effect.

The crawling one

On duty


Off Duty
The Dewback is probably one of the less mechanical (or more organic) characters in the Tatooine landscape. In fact, its popularity earned it some additional screen time in the re-release of the movie, CGed into the vast desert of Tatooine. This latest Dewback does more justice to its movie counterpart in terms of colours, prints and size (thanks to its shorter and chunkier tail). The only movable part on this Dewback is the jaw, which is printed with a row of teeth! Really?!? The saddle is an elaborate affair, too elaborate in fact. The Sandtrooper now has a much more spacious saddle to ride on but the saddle is too bulky for my liking. In the event the Sandtrooper will like to free the Dewback from the saddle so that it can graze (in Tatooine??), there are four green arch bricks to fill the void on the body of the Dewback.

Can, or Cannot?

"It's not my drink ..."
Since this is a "Mos Eisley Cantina" set, the spotlight must therefore fall on the ... Cantina. There are four sections in the building structure - it starts with the brilliantly-designed bar on the left, the band room adjacent to the bar, followed by the sofa set private corner and the entrance area on the extreme right. Comparing this to the meagre dual wall panelled 2004 Cantina, there is little to complain about the highly inflated price. More rooms mean more playability but I can always do with bigger sized rooms in this set.


Moonlighting, Obi Wan?
I like the details and thoughts that were invested in the design of the bar - The golden coins in the drawers for change, the uniquely coloured beverages and not to forget, the concealed pistol behind the counter to defend against the rowdy customers. Looking through the accompanying minifigs, I wonder who is supposed to be bar tending? An oversight?

My fondness index dropped gradually across the other rooms. The two adjacent rooms are definitely iconic but they are way too small and difficult to place the minifies in. Both the band room and sofa room can slide out to allow easy access for the minifigs. Behind these two rooms are the vaporiser tower and an oversized feeding tray. The bone in the tray is apparent leftover from a hearty meal of the Dewback. Thought it's vegetarian? Anyway, by sliding the feeding tray, you will be able to slide the two aforementioned rooms easily. As for the vaporiser, it is, IMO, the best looking and most accurate one to date. Nice design!

Too squeezy for comfort
The entrance structure has a few playable / movable features. The sliding door is very well designed with appropriate tightness. The entire door / wall panel can also hinged open to reveal the interior of the room. The large sand coloured dome above this room can also be lifted via the hinged joints. The multiple hinged joints  in the walls allow the Cantina structure to be displayed in many ways, including keep it for storage. It can be nicely tucked into a squairish footprint which makes storage much easier.


Packed for storage
Building Experience

The box is REALLY long, not one of those with standard dimension for sure. I suspect the elongated profile has something to do with accommodating the box art, which I must say goes down pretty well with me. With the vast desert in the background, the box art recreated the famous scene from Episode IV, where Luke and Han crossed path amongst the thugs of Mos Eisley Cantina.

Taped opening of the box is always welcomed by me, however as soon as the box opened, I was greeted with the disappointment at the absence of the cardboard-backed instruction manuals. As a result, the two booklets and the sticker sheet were rather creased. The 600+ br
icks were spread quite evenly between the five numbered packs, while the Dewback comes packed separately in his own personal polybag.

I do like the bricky coloured bricks used on the Landspeeder and they are quite rare. However, there are waaaaay too much stickers on the Landspeeder. In fact, most of my (crumpled) stickers were spent on the Landspeeder. There are times when stickers can enhance the details, but this is a case of "doing less is better". To make matter worse, they are not easy to apply on the curved surface of the engine parts.


The building part is hardly challenging and I took less than an hour to put this set together. There are quite a fair bit of repeated steps when building the main building structure. Not a big bother but quite a bore.



Minifigs

A total of 8 minifigs come with this set. All of them had at least some relevance to the scene in Tatooine so it does make sense for them to be included. Given the large number of weird looking crooks in Mos Eisley in the movie, a few more colourful characters will certainly be more welcomed (not at the expense of an inflated price of course)


The Bith musicians are, without a doubt, the main talking point of this set. My first impression of them are their canny resemblance to the aliens found in the movie "Mars Attack". After the initial giggles, I do have to say the three of them started to grow on me. The head pieces are custom made with hard plastic rather than rubber. Torso and leg pieces are movie accurate with little to separate the 3 of them. Two of the musicians have their own musical instruments and the third one is presumably the drummer of the 3-man band. I believe I saw more Bith musicians in the movie but in consideration of the limited space in the Cantina, 3 should suffice.


Han Solo is not a surprise inclusion and he does come in abundance of supply in many other sets. This Han is brand new and is only found in the Microfighters MF. There are more details on his signature vest with more pockets and crease lines printed on his torso. This Han comes with 2 faces - a smirky one and a rather lost look. Am I seeing things or are there wrinkles on his face? LEGO, go easy with the details. please.


Luke is brand new too, at least before it makes a second appearance in the UCS Sandcrawler set. The details on his tunic and leg piece are excellent, with the appropriate crease lines printed on both sides of his torso. I believe his hair piece is new too, one that doesn't make him look like a girl with venter-parted hair. His accessory include the blue bladed light sabre and the binoculars for his recce mission.


Only two Greedo's were ever released, both in the old and new Mos Eisley Cantina set. This new Greedo comes with definitely more detailed prints on his torso and leg piece (nice touches of a sagging gun holster printed here). His head piece is made of hard plastic instead of rubber but its colour seems to differ quite a bit from his body. I tried to find some of Greedo's pictures online and concluded that the head and body should be synchronised in colour, so this Greedo is not that accurate after all.

The Sandtrooper is another new variant that does not appear in other sets before. The design of his backpack is not new. While elaborate, it does tend to tip him over backward which makes the Sandtrooper difficult to pose. This new design added plenty of details on his already-detailed helmet and torso. Simply put it, this is a Sandtrooper with a (big) splash of sand all over him! Upon close observation, his black pauldron is printed with very subtle designs too. Other details such as the left shoulder ammo pack print and different knee print designs really appeal to me. I have to say it does stand out amongst the other minifigs included in this set. A word of advice to LEGO, this is probably as far as you can get about detailing, without crossing the line of overdoing.


Obi Wan Kenobi comes in his "older" form, i.e. not the Ewan McGregor form. Surprisingly, his head piece is only printed on one side with grey beard and deep thinking expression. A hood is printed on the back of his torso and I though a real hood (see Wyldstyle in LEGO movie sets) will be nice.

Conclusion

I cannot decide on how I should rate this set. Perhaps my expectations were a little too high when I first learnt about the release of this set so I was a tinge disappointed. But when I ask my self what can be done better, there are not many points I can picked on... perhaps a bigger set so that we can have bigger rooms for play time? Or perhaps more minifigs thrown in to better represent the busy cantina in the movie? My son forced me to decide if this is a "good" or "bad" review so if I have to choose, there are certainly more good's than bad's.

+ Improved Dewback, but what's with the printed teeth?
+ Nice details in the bar counter
+ Eight minifigs! And nice details on them, a tad too much on some of them though

- Cramped rooms that limit playability
- Uninspiring building process

Saturday, August 16, 2014

Review: 7659 Imperial Landing Craft


Set ID: 7659 Imperial Landing Craft
Number of Pieces: 471
Year of Release: 2007
Minifigs: 5
Purchased Price: About SGD 126

Nostalgia has always been my soft spot. With every release, there are always more sets falling into the "vintage" zone for the Star Wars range, and without the time and space to build everyone of them, more and more sets are slipping out of my radar range and sit quietly in my exclusive LEGO Star Wars Store room. From time to time, there will be this unexplained gravity towards these older sets, which brings back the nostalgic good old days.

Until recent years, I have always mistaken this set as a cheaper and smaller variant of the Imperial Shuttle. After constructing the UCS Imperial Shuttle two years ago, I had categorically ignored the existence of this set, thinking that it will be a waste of time to go back to a variant of humble proportion. It took a mishap in my LEGO storeroom, where I had a whole stack of boxes tumbling over me, that this set caught my eyes again. Amidst the mess in the storeroom, I somehow gravitated towards the box, picked it up, dust it, and for the first time, took a good look at the picture on the box (It was really THAT dramatic) "Pick me! Pick me!", the box seemed to call out to me. Without a second thought, I took it home.
"Pick me, Pick me!"
Unlike many other sets that I have built to date, the compelling reason why I wanted to build this was solely to satisfy my curiosity. If this is not a variant of the Imperial Shuttle, then what is this weird looking craft? Having little recollection of it in the movies, I resorted to flip through my DK Visual Dictionary and Vehicle Guide. Nothing found. That simply shows how little its significance in the movies. Some website classified this set under the "Expanded Universe" range which I do not collect too. Despite all of these confusions, the box still appealed to me, and for two hours after I did that, I was not disappointed.

So, what is IT actually?

Pretty cramped cabin with only 2 seats
It will be fundamentally wrong to say that the Landing craft bears little resemblance to the Imperial Shuttle. Its triangular fin profile, rotatable wings, white body and sloping canopy forms the familiar silhouette of the Imperial Shuttle. But unlike the Shuttle's prestigious cargo, the Imperial Landing craft is used mainly for deployment of common troops and logistics. This craft has a wide body to serve the purpose and it is designed to carry four passengers - two with seats and two ... without?!?  Guess the budget was cut in the last minute and the designer has to forgo the other two chairs?

Hinged canopy will be much preferred

The two troopers without seats are to be placed behind the spring loaded cannons, supposedly operated by the two deprived troopers. The pilot has it easier with his exclusive cockpit, and a big one too. A 2X1 printed SNOT brick serves as the control panel for the pilot. Despite the luxury of space, the designer did not intend to hinge the canopy to the cockpit, so it became quite a hassle to always remove the canopy entirely whenever the pilot needs to access the cockpit.

Clip on mechanisms on the spine
The troopers are able to access the fuselage via two ways: (1) the six hinged curved panels covering the fuselage or (2) "De-bone" the Landing Craft. Allow me to explain option (2), which is a highlight for this set. Those who own the 8096 Emperor's Palpatine's Shuttle will understand this design concept well, where the fuselage can be totally exposed (for enhanced playability I supposed) by lifting the lid over it.

In this craft, the lid (formed by the six curved panels) is part of the spine that runs through the length of the craft, connecting the cockpit on one end, and the wings and engine on the other. Two cleverly designed hinges clipped the two parts together tightly when you need them to integrate again.

Two long arch bricks form the undercarriage of the Landing craft and provided the perfect stand for displaying the craft. It would be ideal if the undercarriage are retractable to give the ship a sleeker silhouette after taking off.

Ammunition

Front facing hammer like spring loaded missiles
Troop carrier needs protection too. There are probably less than 5 (maybe 3) Star Wars sets in my collection that comes with the "big-a**" spring loaded cannon. Off the top of my head, one of them was the twin-chambered TIE bomber released some years back, whose cannon design was critically put down by me in my review. But not this one. Although they share the same firing mechanism, the cannon barrels (yes, plural as there are two of them) in this Landing craft are well concealed in the fuselage and can be operated by a quick flick of a switch disguised as a forward facing flashlight. Reloading of the cannon is also an effortless affair.

Bomb chambers located at the back wall of cabin
The Landing craft also carries four luminous drop bombs as part of its armoury. These bombs are placed on a pair of latches that can be tilted to slide the bombs out of the fuselage. As innovative as the mechanism might be, the bombs do find it challenging at times to exit. The long laser blasters of the troopers are secured onto the floor board of the fuselage using some single studded 2X1, but the weapons do come off quite easily during play time. A few well designed clip bricks might serve better in this case.

Foldable wings


A fair bit of Technic parts are committed at the rear of the craft, primarily for the working parts of the rotating wings. The mesh of gears and hinges combined well to operate the wings, via the rotation of a small knob located at the discreet rear of the craft. The wings are not overly design to minimise the weight sustained by the rotating mechanism. This was a major problem for the UCS Imperial Shuttle whose similar mechanism is not designed adequately to move its huge heavy wings.

Building Process


It always take a lot of courage to open the pre 2008 sets for the reason that the brick packs are not sequentially numbered. Only in my most masochistic self (and plenty of time on hand) will I consider building those, especially brick counts close to those of the UCS ISD. But at less than 500 pieces, this set does not warrant much courage and truth to be told, it was a fun building experience.

Starting from the box. It has probably one of the simplest designs you can ever get in terms of box art - Just a desert scene in the background and featuring the landing craft firing its weapons in the fore. The back of the box showcased the various playable features with a separate panel featuring other sets released in the same wave of that season. This is a really old-school feature that we don't see often nowadays. A Star Wars 30th anniversary logo on the side panel gives the set some exclusivity points too.
The content consists of an instruction booklet and 7 packs of bricks in various sizes. It is always useful to have the smaller bricks in separate packs especially when some sorting are required for unlabelled packs. What caught my attention then was the large amount of Technic and gear parts, which were subsequently used for the engine and folding wings mechanisms. There were also plenty of whites (duh ...) with a few other grey bits here and there to break the monotony.


Complex gear system but interesting building design
During the 2 hour building process, this set does not come across to me as a 2007 at all. Some of the steps are so unique that I hardly even see them in recent years. Two technique impressed me most: (1) The firing mechanism of the forward facing spring loaded cannons, and (2) How the wings were pegged down to ensure exact symmetry during part of the building process, before the pegs are removed later in the steps.



Minifigs

As mentioned earlier, this vehicle probably made such a quick cameo appearance in the movie that I was not able to pick up who flew it and who used it in the first place. But I am quite certain it should not have been flown by a TIE  Interceptor pilot! The pilot comes with a black unprinted head piece concealed inside a well designed helmet. The torso is only printed on the front side with panel design and belt. The rest of the minifig are generally black with no additional prints. his helmet probably scores highest with me for its detailed design and close resemblance to its movie counterparts.




Four troopers were included in this set - two Stormtroopers and two Sandtroopers. Very little separate them as the latter has the luxury of an additional orange pauldron. Al troopers come with unprinted black head pieces, which seems practical back in 2007. Nobody really cares about whats inside those nicely designed helmets at that point of time, I supposed. Those helmets have not evolved much over the years and they still look pretty cool from the today's standard. The torso piece is printed on both sides with details of chest armour in the front and panelling at the back. Leg pieces are plain white without prints.

Conclusions

I have a feeling that the sales number for this set was dismal, to say the least. It does not have the most eye catching box art nor an instantly recognised silhouette. It is unfair to judge this set from a 2014 perspective but if we backtrack 7 years ago, I will be very impressed with its design finesse and brick choices. Once we sort out its identity crisis (EU or classic?), it certainly deserves a place in my collection.

+ Very interesting building technique. Quite complex but interesting - plucked in pegs and remove later to maintain symmetry
+ Well designed bomb mechanism and spring loaded missiles
+ Big cockpit, but can try to design for 2

- Rifle compartment in cabin should be clip on for better security
- 2 chairs for 4 occupants? Budget cut?
- Why is there is TIE pilot flying this?